Beneath the Cards, by Garrett Adelstein

As the text mounts toward Jack-Four, Garrett’s memories become more accurate. He uses quotations and conversations more than generalities. He moralizes less, not needing to fill the chapters with as much commentary. In sum, the book is getting better and is more truthfully indicative of who Garrett is. My ongoing theory is this will matter during the crisis to come.

Garrett’s takes on his mental health remain sympathetic yet a bit comical. At one point in Chapter 39 he describes staying in bed for four months while his girlfriend weeps helplessly in the living room. First off, no one stays in a relationship like this, so he was not likely in his bedroom for four months. What was more likely happening was a mopey but reasonable staycation which was wearing on a girl who wanted to do normal young people things. He describes consuming some burgers as if they were eight-balls or as if he had become Brandon Fraser, when in reality the main symptoms of his indulgence were that he emerged “pale” and had put on a freshman fifteen. Second, when you can afford such a luxury of time to yourself, you might well just take the days and weeks off that you want. People cubicling their life away would love to play a few weeks hide and seek in the bedroom with food and Friends. This is really Garrett’s success as a poker player, not the failure. Performance at the table is exhausting and Garrett performs at the very highest level. Actors and athletes will take plenty of time babying themselves through recovery; indeed, they are notorious for their eccentric self-care.

Still, the man is distraught. His issues are real, just not particularly dire. He weeps at a party surrounded by people who love him: nothing is good enough. He’s not home bound or incelibate; in fact, he is inspired to gamble and to go out with fun company to add some variety to his staycation. Garrett wins even then, taking hundreds of thousands off Keating in red or black and half a mil overall. “I needed that,” he adds amusingly. Life, even when bad, is always good for Garrett.

However, he soon lashes out at Jen, still finding boundaries. They are no longer an item. Garrett is making his life worse, as all men do while they find their place and purpose in the world. With no real wanderlust experienced or social lessons learned, with only poker and alcohol and arrogance to lean on, Garrett is still a boy who naturally slips into the relative purposelessness he has coasted on since becoming a high school badass. Garrett has not learned self-management and so experiences this normal growth process as catastrophe. There’s also not enough drama in the Beneath the Cards narrative yet, so Garrett the writer leans hard upon the mental theme.

For many and for those with more pressing obligations, this suffering would take years, even a lifetime to master. Not for Garrett, who is on top of it immediately. Enter lists and philanthropy and new determination. He decides, preemptively, that the universal corrective of CBT will do it. He’s not misguided; there’s just not that much wrong with him. Whatever he does, as long as he does something, he will be fine. Enter the psychologists, who he tests out like personal chefs. He finds a pleasing woman and gets therapy started. He’s impressed she doesn’t judge him, as if the other ones all terrorized him or as if the usual practice is to judge the client. This is a funny chapter disguised as a serious one; there’s this Being There quality to Garrett’s story, where everything just kinds of moves along without anyone knowing why but the reader.

Garrett gets what he needed of course: he has to let his down days and feelings be. He wanted to “judge” himself but didn’t want anyone else to “judge” him. This is the usual mousetrap people who get consumed by the idea of “judgement” set: the subject wants exclusivity on standards but only uses his monopoly to incapacitate himself.

Meanwhile, heartbroken Jen has rediscovered religion. She tests him out when he returns to her, making sure he agrees to go to Israel as a symbol of his seriousness. (Humorously, he refers to this effort as a Hail Mary; Garrett just surfs over and through all obstacles.) Garrett passes the test, throws Mykonos into the mix, and the pair are reunited in happiness and homeland.

As this part ends and his streaming era begins in Part 7, Garrett finds a life coach who gets him into thinking everyone lives in “mental containers.” The concept helps Garrett reconsider his choices; he can simply move to a new “container” if he’s feeling bad. It’s all very light but the point is the ago: agency. You can make choices, and when you make a choice, life changes. Really stubborn or traumatized people resist this, but Garrett is not really bound to anything but his ambitions. The placebo works. Container on, bro.

Meanwhile, his selected psychologist Tamar is doing fine work with Garrett; under her purview and his insistence he will even reconcile with his mother. He’s an easy patient, one who wants to be well, so it’s not particularly compelling material. However, one thing about Garrett’s process is very interesting: he finds no real answer or explanation for his “perfectionism.” Now, Garrett says he “realized how” it happened, and presents himself as satisfied with the exploration, but notice how it is mere words. No logical chain of events is presented. Garrett suggests it has something to do with his mother and her abusiveness. However, he could have just as easily been defeated by her words, or become some sort of addict, or really reacted in almost any way. This would be the moment for getting to the heart of the matter, but instead, we gloss over the very core of his personality: no real answer, here in the chapter of answers. Is it the fascinatingly backwards father? He isn’t mentioned in this passage, which seems like a jaw-dropping omission. I hope we return to this issue and theme, but time is running out.

Of course, my interests matter little, because what does is Garrett’s well-being and happiness. We can live, and do, on illusions. His personality hinge is more important from a writing and biographical point of view. It seems to me that Garrett is a healthy and normal person in spite of his parenting, not that he is a neurotic because of them: a fine difference. The lesson could be is that those who want to be happy will find the way; those who do not are the tough cases. If his parents gave him this gift, did they not succeed after all? The world may be upside down, but everything ticks on. Everyone moves on. We see this state of affairs in everything, everywhere, even in, maybe especially in, the sanitized autobiography of a high performing, successful man worth emulating.

*

Lightning Strikes Twice, or Part 8, is the most exciting section of Beneath the Cards so far. Garrett plays in huge games and makes huge scores, sometimes having to come back from what looks like a terrible loss. We meet his most interesting opponent, Cocky Banker. We learn more about Garrett’s interactions with the slippery Ryan Feldman, who will figure prominently in Jack-Four.

Cocky Banker is not named for some reason but is clearly financier/lawyer David Peters (not to be confused with the tournament player). After bravely naming so many names, it’s not clear why Garrett makes this omission. Peters will go on to lose a truly high-stakes arbitration case which found that he embezzled millions from his firm. Poker will be over for Peters, but not before he loses what sounds like over three million, possibly much more, to Garrett. Peters makes Garrett rich and comfortable and ready to become the player you know him as.

It’s worth noting that poker relies on such money. Names like Dennis Blieden and Thomas Goldstein figure prominently in the high-stakes annals. The truth is there are no games at the high stakes without all the criminals and ne’er do wells laundering their illicit gains. If you were so naive as to be surprised at the recent Britney/C Ye/Hank stuff, it’s time to get the felt out of your eyes: games need available cash to run this big, and that stuff doesn’t get distributed by squares. (Don’t forget the guy from the swamp who punted off all his stolen Covid loan cash! They were all so happy to get his money, then got a little quiet when they found out where it came from.) However, the point is not that these people are corrupt – corruption is everywhere – but that high-stakes poker is not the same as the dads wagering their spending money on Saturday night.

This also means that money that must come from other sources than the games themselves to make big stakes go. For this reason, there is not just money laundering in poker, but the aspirational dollars of vloggers and social media grifters. Stakes scamming and unpaid loans, often accomplished through various forms of flattery and lying, is a significant piece of the poker economy. This includes anything as inert as ridiculous mark-ups to outright broken promises and theft. There is a new scandal every week because poker is a grey economy market and a hustle: it must be like this, despite the whining of our industry’s various Pollyannas. Garrett is involved in this, just not at the losing end. He will curate line-ups and be faced with minor moral choices, especially once Ryan Feldman becomes a big part of his life. Garrett’s role in our dramas is not to cheat but to live off the conflict stolen, dubious money creates. This is the role of all big winning poker players. We must be comfortable with this, be stupid enough to live in ignorance of it, or else move on. Garrett is absolutely fine with it, maybe too much so. He is bored by small stakes and working-class money; he literally stays in bed like a supermodel until the potential check has enough zeros. This is one of his edges.

Preludes are leading Garrett to the way he handled Jack-Four. He has already caught and dealt with a team of cheaters. Now, in Chapter 50, Garrett is briefly “joke-betted” out of $28,000 by Peters, who refuses to pay off a river call. Yet he ends up recovering the money, astonishingly; in fact, as I have noted before, it’s been a theme. That said, Garrett does let go of $150,000 that Peters owes him, so while his record isn’t perfect, Garrett’s character type is perfectly clear. I am surprised and impressed. Of course, this will have its own consequences during Jack-Four, and not everyone will agree with my admiration.

Feldman is a great character match for Garrett. He’s not a winning player but loves poker and loves making the game happen. Feldman is an operator. He is likely making tens if not hundreds of thousands in backdoor rake and app games and bribes and back-scratching; Garrett even catches him in one messy moment when an outraged pro screams at Ryan about his seat payment. Yet don’t confuse Garrett with some white knight of the felt; Garrett curates the games, too, weeding out competition when he can. It’s unseemly but it’s real poker. This is the storytelling we’ve been looking for.

The writing is especially plot driven during these passages and so works well enough. As for my interest in the A.I. and the book’s editing, I want only to dwell on one line on page 211, when a terrible, whinging metaphor is chosen to describe his wait on the Cocky Banker. Now I know it’s possible Garrett didn’t choose this “Russian roulette” comparison or if he did, that he put little thought into it. It makes him look bad and petty. The point being, the A.I. is as double edged as any cheat code: here the poorly chosen phrase makes the writer look like a worse person than he is. Think about that before you turn your soul over to the robot.

After a ton of action and interest, the section closes with some more corny reflections. “I… continued to struggle with how to reconcile such massive amounts of money at the expense of others.” These crocodile tears are just too much after a sequence of destroying the competition. Of course, I understand that Garrett feels the emptiness of gambling for a living, much as the stockbroker sometimes wishes he had dug a ditch somewhere; remember that one? And he still can, of course. What’s equally true, however, is that this phony bad conscience never stopped him from seeking out CB, Neverwin and all his marks. Garrett won’t even bother to play in sustainable games! In other words, much of Garrett’s writing includes emotional revisionism for the sake of conflict, even in a chapter where extra conflict is simply surplus.

All this aside, what really matters is how Garrett’s character and mind work, because we are nearing the big moment. We know Garrett wants to win and that he feels he deserves all the money. We know about his competitiveness, and we know even about his paranoia: Garrett is no slouch, no mark. How will this play out on his ultimate stage, Hustler Casino Live?

*

It’s post-Covid and Garrett is about to become Hustler Casino Live’s star. First, however, he will take a revealing dip in results on the pedestrian reboot of High Stakes Poker. This was an interesting juxtaposition, because reduced to a stream, the formerly beloved show is little more than just another big game; to this day, Pokergo hasn’t figured this out. Instead, it’s the Hustler’s more crafted production that will become the metaphorical HSP and secure the attention of the poker world. Garrett will experience the show’s classic highs and lows soon enough.

While many in poker are suffering in the aftermath of the overwrought pandemic, our man continues living the high life. He has made some money from app games, dodging all the agents/thieves that plagued us in the early 2020s. Even better, Garret has been working on his game with PioSolver. Garrett at last marries Jen. Their personalized vows in Chapter 59, Joy and Anguish, seem to indicate a strong and stable love that revolves around Garrett’s career in gambling; both their proclamations talk about gambling. Still, it is striking that the reader essentially knows nothing about her; Jen is only a love interest who believes in supporting her moody partner. Her interests, her passions, her contradictions are completely opaque. Does A.I. know about the Bechdel test? Curiously, this lack of depth seems to suggest a very human approach: either Garrett doesn’t really want to talk about Jen or doesn’t really know how.

What is transparent is the reality of Garrett’s mentality: this is the Anguish. Garrett says he has managed his career for five years without much of a hiccup, but the big loss on HSP will blow all that up. It’s back to couple weeks of munching, which he takes to mean the sky is falling. Garrett claims it is depression, telling us how disappointed he is to have fallen apart, but what else could possibly be expected? He loses hundreds of thousands of dollars and feels humiliated by his questionable play. Of course he is going to be morose when he has fallen short of his standards! His imaginary mental issues may sell books or make for good chats with Joey Ingram, poker’s Oprah, but even a cursory examination of the situation shows he is experiencing a natural performance low. No one takes a huge loss and is unaffected. Poker players in many ways have it worse than athletes: imagine a Wimbledon where the runner-up hands over a few million to the winner. Garrett lives in a bit of a bubble, as many high achievers do, insulated from negativity until the crash. He is Serena, oblivious to the skills of others and therefore especially depressed when things go badly. His behavior and feelings are all of a piece with his personality – not with his dramatic claims of mental health issues. Feel your feelings, my dude.

Meanwhile, his partnership with Ryan is running a bit rough. Intrigue abounds. Reading between the lines, Garrett is taking a bit too much from the various props and friends and staked players Ryan is putting in the game. The side plot with Chris Chen is interesting. Caught in between his own excellence at production and his greed, Ryan finds Garrett to be a problem as much as he is a blessing. The two tangle. Ryan makes the most of a fish he promotes as Dylan the Villain. Garrett wipes him out. Alan Keating, a more formidable presence and player, enters the scene, giving Ryan new leverage: does he really need Garrett?

Once again, Garrett rises to the occasion and outmuscles Ryan. Despite the litany of fake worries over taking other people’s money, Garrett fights to keep his place on the show, threatening to more or less take his viewership elsewhere. Ryan is stymied. Next stop, Jack-Four.

It’s worth noting that Garrett brings up the Postle scandal to explain the sequence of events at this time. This insertion is good story telling, and leads to an interaction in Chapter 58, HCL Takeover. Garrett learns that Ryan’s Hustler Casino Live will not be the “black box” type of stream where staff has no access to hole cards. As I have written elsewhere, this is a major point and yet not one that necessarily makes HCL look bad. To control the show and be the new High Stakes Poker, Ryan had understood the value of direction and story-telling. He simply had to have knowledge of what was happening on the table in order to direct the show in a compelling fashion. Notice that this puts a premium on entertainment: Ryan knows his business. It is a remarkable difference in approach from the latest, DOA LATB incarnation, which will lockdown the card and board information from human knowledge and interference. In other words, to make a great show, Garrett, the players, and we the audience had to entrust Ryan and his staff with real time knowledge of the game that Postlegate had warned against. Was it the right decision? I have no problem with it, but the consequence is obviously a potential security leak. As Garrett implies, it’s not just a leak but one left in the hands of someone he did not really trust, Ryan Feldman.

I’m excited to find out what happens. We’ve reached the final chapter, one that is simply and appropriately titled after the notorious hand. This one is many times the length of the average Beneath the Cards chapter: a strong hint about how much this event mattered to Garrett and to all of poker.

*

His recollection of September 29, 2022 picks up with Garrett tucking two million underneath his chair. He goes over his announced competition, which includes Rabia Hussain, a Saudi immigrant who married Charles Lew and transliterated her first name to Robbi. It’s an odd name for a dynamic woman, but a striking one for someone obsessed with being seen, if not with fame itself. Like Garrett, she was vain and competed on game shows. She clearly had work done toward the Instagram look. On the Nick Vertucci show, she describes getting into medical sales, a go to for post-baccalaureates who need unusual amounts of income and can wear a skirt well. At the time of Jack-Four, she’s into crypto but admits the money is gone, which seems relevant. Robbi publicly admits to adultery (“the seven-year itch is a very real thing”), angling for attention even from her disloyalties: she is a performer at heart. Her entrepreneur/attorney husband, “a saint” who “deserves all the money in the world” for putting up with her indiscretions, didn’t get involved in the Hustler affair much; their marriage is doubtless a dead one.

Robbi was somehow attached to Jacob “Rip” Chavez, a L.A. and Las Vegas schemer. She described her friendship with him as “too close for comfort” and an “emotional affair.” Jacob had been involved in the vaping/marijuana business, I recall. Garrett noted that he was connected with Jake Paul and had been charged with some sort of assault. At the same time, Rip was a much more pleasant and mild person than you’d expect; on screen he seemed uncomfortable and more naturally shy and I can imagine the affair not being consummated. Still, the pair really were suspicious. They seem to me like unwanted spouses who had found each other. I’d imagine Rip had his eyes on Charles’ money as much as he did on Robbi, but Jack-Four probably ended up putting an end to that lead. Robbi describes Rip and Charles as friends, which was “weird” to her, and which is probably the only sane thing she said during the NV interview.

What is striking in Beneath the Cards was not the maudlin pair, Robbi and Rip, but that Garrett frames them as good, or at least trained, players. I find this strange and possibly a revisionist justification for what Garrett would ultimately do. Now remember that Robbi had said her first competitive game was in 2021, just a year before her high-stakes appearance with Garrett, Rip, and others (which, by the way somehow included an ultimately bemused Phil Ivey himself). From the hands I had seen, both were fish. They had avoided conflict on stream; find their AQ vs AQ hand for an amusing example of both bad play and soft collusion. Robbi reported she’d read Poker for Dummies, so there’s that seminal text under her belt. She claims to have stopped “studying cash” in January of 2022, now preferring tournaments. She claimed she’d studied with Faraz Jaka when she moved on to tournaments after a heavy six months of the cash grind, meaning at best she had eight months of, well, tournament strategy by September 29th. Yet this is a bold exaggeration: it turns out to be just two sessions, as recounted by Faraz. Yet, she also says she has quit her job to play poker; from her tone I don’t even quite believe that statement – what was she calling her job and if she was a corporate high-flyer at that point, how could she be so frivolous?

Anyway, anyone in the poker cash world understands that it is impossible that she can play well at this point in her career. Later, after the scandal, she will not be grinding outside of celebrity splashes but will arise from the scandal to claim to be a professional poker player on various internet trash sites. Robbi claimed on the Nick Vertucci show to have played as high as $5,000/$10,000 with a million of her own money. These are absurd stakes, even higher than Garrett himself has ever played, as far as I can tell. When did she have time for this extravagance and what chapter was she at in Dummies? Suspiciously, she couldn’t name anyone from this game when a naturally curious Nick pressed her. Instead, she equivocates and resorts to gangster-land movie clichés, calling them “heavy-hitters” Mr. Wong style, and that they were “playing for fun” to ward off further inquiry. (The theme here being that Robbi lives in a fantasy world, which I think matters.) Her husband comes up during the NV show appearance, too; maybe she sat on his stack for an orbit. This sort of backing off from a claim is a pattern; she’ll do it immediately following the hand and Garrett’s capture of her dialog is compelling.

Rereading the hand history, I was surprised that I had forgotten certain details. Of course, these are no doubt burned into Garrett’s mind. Robbi had minraised on the turn; a mostly nonsensical or perhaps just poor play, depending on what you interpret her as doing and thinking. While Garrett contemplated the action, Robbi acted suspiciously, but Garrett again repeats his odd claim that she was not a novice. The truth seems to be somewhere in between: no one can play even 1/3 hold’em profitably after a quick tour of Dummies, certainly not this high-stakes game with the monster Adelstein himself… oh and those other bums. The plan had to have been this: find an edge or lose. Unless, that is, there was another goal, a goal she might not have ever shared because it was, for once, not a lie: to be a star under the bright lights. Either way, Robbi was out of her league and this matters. Has anyone discussed her simply being drugged and high? She definitely acted like she was on something, and Rip had an interest in keeping her that way.

It’s curious that Rip is mad even when she makes the call and wins. If they had been communicating, the signaling seems to have failed. In fact, this is very likely, because the difficulty of actually getting quality information and transmitting it was likely beyond Rip and Robbi. This is not the MIT blackjack team. Further, as much as HCL did and does have security flaws, this isn’t how the crime would go down. Jack-Four, as exciting as it is as a scandal, was amateur hour, obviously. Garrett’s writing is at its most detailed at this point: it is not a surprise, but this is the climax of Beneath the Cards in every way.

Now, the public has long demanded an exposé and imagined all sorts of extraordinary criminal particulars, but I can imagine a much more plausible story, one that takes the pressure off well-worn inquiries into the technicals of what really happened. Robbi’s words after the game don’t just imply guilt, they imply a certain kind of guilt. She is uncomfortable about two things.

One, she bizarrely is worried about the “production,” forgetting the real point is the game. That is because she is no poker player, but another soul who never got their time in the sun. The game shows and movies she never was cast in have brought her here, to HCL theater. Robbi clearly doesn’t even care about the poker, and therefore she doesn’t respect the seriousness of “cheating.” Winning with an unlikely hand will make her a star. She is attracted, remember to tournaments and even selects, of all people, The Toilet master of the crazy, camera-friendly play, to pretend to teach her. Then, when it goes wrong, all she wants is the game to continue, because she wants the callback. She doesn’t want to be fired. She gives the money back to Garrett because he is the amanuensis for the director she never got to work for.

Two, her public admission of adultery means she carries shame and guilt. To be caught again is an emotional disaster, because she knows the cost of actually cheating. It was fun to put the money in the pot with jack high, but she does not want any part of it once Garrett, who can be a forbidding masculine figure, stares her down in judgement. Robbi burbles through the aftermath, and she babbled before, too, which Garrett is keen to note. She was uncomfortable because she can’t play poker and likely has an extremely crappy collusion plan with a fellow loser. Now, with the heat really on, now she is lost. Robbi got the role she wanted but the secret is that not everyone can handle the role. So she gives the small fortune back just to feel better; is this necessarily the behavior of a cheater, or is it the peculiar behavior of a traumatized person and a cheater? The flaw in the common theory is that real cheats try to get away with it; they don’t just hand over the racks of lucre. As we know from the preceding life story, Garrett is no mark and his life has been building to a crisis which tests that skill. Conversely, Robbi is no master thief, but even if she is not high, she is clearly confused and under pressure from her quasi-lover and staker Rip. And even if that’s not true, there are people who are so neurotic that when the crisis comes, they are completely baffled and useless. Don’t seat Robbi in the exit row.

So, did she full-stop cheat? This might not be the right question. It’s probably more like, or exactly like, the “emotional affair” with Rip. As in, to what degree did Robbi cheat? Disoriented by drugs to manage her insane life choices and her “too close” relationship with Rip, completely out of her league in games no sane person would encourage her to play and really not understanding poker at all, she may well have looked to Rip for a nod. Is that cheating? Yes, but…. does it matter? The dark truth is that a savvy pro could say, sure, look at Rip, take this guy’s advice. Of course, people don’t really do this much in practice, if only for appearances, but my point is that the form of cheating was probably collusion, and even more it was rather clearly two fools in over their head, each using each other for different ends. Is it not sweet irony that Robbi probably spent more time interpreting Rip’s signals than reading her opponent’s tells? There is a lot of humor in the Jack-Four story. If these two lost bunnies were giggling at Poker for Dummies underneath the sheets but with their leather pants on, Garrett was naked and fuming like Brock Samson, studying their game footage, generating ever more advantage, predating and salivating in the dark for the EV on screen.

In other words, a classic mismatch. A classic L.A. story. In fact, where is the screenplay? Who owns the rights? How about one more windfall for sun-running Garrett, or has Robbi Jade Lew beat him to the punch? “You let me do this to you,” Robbi had jibber-jabbered after the hand; but what if she really can beat him when it counts for even more money? Will they have to share the rights and be tied together in paperwork for ever after? Will they take meetings, shake hands, and get her into showbiz after all? Stranger things have happened in Hollywood.

Beneath the Cards does not end here, so I have a little more work to do. Garrett will go on to address the fallout, both public and private. He provides a series of appendix items which appear to be supporting documents surrounding Jack-Four. I’ll go through them. Yet I’ve climbed the mountain, to use one of Garrett’s endless clichés. I admire Garrett’s willingness to take what he wants in life. In reading his story, I got to see the clear pattern that prepared him to make the choice to take the money back. I saw how his paranoia has served him so well in identifying unusual game dynamics. Garrett is a poker hero in many ways. He’s lived a good life. He has misconstrued a performer’s normal sufferings for some sort of mental handicap, but it was useful in providing drama through a surprisingly smooth poker career until Jack-Four. It’s time for both of us to mop up and see what the crisis did to and for him in the final chapters.

*

In Chapter 66, The Internet Mob, Garrett says the most important line of the book to his new wife Jen: “Poker… is a foreign language… You have to be fluent to see the whole picture.” This has been true the whole time and is equally true with respect to who Garrett is. The attentive reader has seen through his exaggerated dramas and now has insight into the real one, Robbi Jade Lew and the Jack-Four.

Above all, Garrett does not compromise much and has a healthy self-regard. Not only has he sniffed out Robbi’s questionable decision and retrieved the money, Garrett ends his night on Hustler Casino Live and will not go back on the show despite Nick Vertucci’s request. This has been his pattern throughout Beneath the Cards: doing what he thinks is right for himself, having some normal doubts, then recasting his response as somehow mentally debilitating. Garrett shoots first and asks questions later. This is a good way to be, especially as a high-stakes performer.

The chapter, though, is really about society and the failure of imaginary values. Garrett says he “had no legs to stand on” facing the incoming volleys of social pressure over the hand. Yet how can this possibly be, when he has spent scores of pages assuring us about the value of therapy and mental containers? The answer is, of course, that personality props are no substitute for values, for a philosophy of life. And now the emptiness of Garrett and many poker players makes more sense. It is not that gambling is the problem – everything is gambling – it is the lack of education, the bro culture which is at the heart of poker that sinks so many. What values are a poker players’? What opinions does he have? If we are in a post-literate world, bro culture is its vanguard; therapy culture is not far behind. The emptiness Garrett feels and the reader senses about him is nothing particularly abnormal, but it is about what Garrett did not finish at home or at school or on vacation or at any point in his life: he did not create an inner man to stand up to the outer world. Propping himself up for competition was a good process and helped make money, but this is mere skin-deep hypnosis and twenty-four hours long. Feeling good about himself, not judging himself, and breathing deeply before breakfast could never replace having a code to mitigate and interpret the storm of public opinion and the world itself.

Fortunately, Garrett has his wife, Jen. She tries to support him in the hour of need. Yet it is naturally not enough. Garrett the inner man is out of control and past reason. He ignores her and leaves a “meandering” message on social media which the cheap seats seize upon. It’s only going to get worse this way. All his themes have come home. “Five million people read and judged it.” What a curious statement. Again, he wants to reserve judgement for himself, so when others have opinions, he is hurt and angry. It’s predictable therapy culture 101. Because his approach to life is only a prop to feel better, he only wounds himself in leaning on it in the moment of crisis. “It was a disastrous idea on my part… I should’ve known better than most.” Why? He really seems to know very little about anything other than poker strategy. Garrett criticizes himself but how could he really have known what to do? He naturally thinks his public persona is about “execution” because he is a performer. Yet he did “execute” on the felt; now we are talking about how to proceed and deal with the consequences. With no real guidance from without or by ethics from within, he struggles. Beneath the Cards demonstrates Garrett is a contemporary man, an emblem of hustle culture, a bro with a wallet and a metal detector instead of a compass. “Apparently, I still hadn’t learned my lesson.” Of course he hadn’t, for what had he studied but cards and feeling good? It’s almost not his fault.

In the next chapter, Garrett doubles down on the importance of how he got the money from her in the moments immediately after the hand. Robbi, Garrett insists, had offered to give it back and he took it, but the public story would become that Garrett asked for it back. To the “internet mob,” as Garrett calls the public, this matters. Garrett thinks this because he is all presentation, all performer. Garrett is the puppet on the stage who is the mirror of the crowd, one which wants to make him a bully and Robbi a victim in a tinny morality play. Yet how the chips came back to him is mostly a distinction without a difference. Again, without a value system, Garrett is caught up in the thinner concerns of the moment. The fact is that the two met and the money was transferred; Ryan can’t even be a good faith witness to this as he himself says the company can’t facilitate deals. It is, of course, useful to know that Robbi wanted to bury the Jack-Four incident and so reimbursed him, but if he had suggested it and she agreed, it would make no significant difference. We are seeing, as I thought all along, how character matters in a crisis.

And it continues to, because having read the previous three hundred pages, we know that Garrett will not compromise. Nick soon requests Garret return the money so that the games can go on and everyone can keep their beak wet. Yet this is Garrett’s most honest and clear and maybe only deeply held belief: that he is owed, that no one will get him, that he will not accept injustice, that he will not compromise easily. He is powerful yet a bit brittle. These are strong echoes of the father influence, a man who was so played by life. The second part of the Jack-Four drama, therefore, begins ominously. Is Garrett about to be outplayed, too? It hasn’t happened much on the felt, but the hostile court of public opinion is higher stakes than he has ever played.

*

The most intense descriptions in Garrett Adelstein’s autobiography arrive only after the notorious Jack-Four incident, not during or before. Beginning in Chapter 68, Robbi’s “Hip,” Garrett runs through supporting information and speculations that confirm my idea that Jack-Four was an incompetent collusion conspiracy. In many cases he doesn’t even bother using paragraphs, but bulleted lists. He is thinking of a case, of an imaginary day in the court of public opinion. Yet Garrett reminds us of so many odd things and has so many conflicting, compelling thoughts that I can see how the conspiracy may have involved more people, even while retaining its essentially foolish nature.

A number of new characters must also be introduced. There’s Darren “Beanz” Attebery, HC Floorman Luis Concha, and HCL tech Bryan Sagbigsal, among others. I learn many details I had missed the first time around. Each of these three will do or say extremely suspicious things. Another interesting turn is that Rip abandoned Robbi as the scandal intensified, even sending compromising information to Garrett, who I suppose must have seemed to have the upper hand at this point. Rip had had to retreat back to his marriage, perhaps allowing for a reversal of perspective. He oddly started to frame her as a liar, as he was her victim. Meanwhile, Robbi was falling apart in interviews but remained buoyed by her ability to tell strange stories the poker news hosts liked. A credible public saw Garrett as the bully and Robbi as victim. However, her behavior always suggested she had done something wrong. The question being, what?

Making sense of the rogue’s gallery Robbi surrounds herself could explain her web of confusion. Robbi had cheated on Charles more than once, according to her interview on the NV show, but was reluctant to come fully clean about Rip, only acknowledging “an emotional affair.” While this is a distinction with a difference, it’s also simply an affair, period. Therefore, it may well be the case that she did not want to upset her husband any further and was hanging on to her platonic explanation. Remember that she described Charles Lew as a “saint,” implying she had been forgiven, but what if all that was probational? Now the mysterious $20,000 payment to Darren “Beanz” Attebury could make sense: perhaps it was a blackmail payment. In fact, what if she had been drawn or merely nudged into the collusion/cheating scheme under threat of further disclosures? Now she had a clear motive to get involved in the schemes of the unsavory people she associated with. Not unrelated, at one point some “gangsta” has a provocative, almost threatening message passed on to her by Julio Arredondo, another HCL player.

Which brings us to the key staff at the hustler. Two people merit serious attention: Luis Concha the floor and Bryan Sagbigsal, an audio/visual tech. Both had access to the control room, but importantly, Bryan may have had necessary additional access to the network which was documented as compromised by the Bulletproof information; Garrett summarizes in Appendix L. This is important, remember, because the main known leak of the HCL RFID system is that a person sitting with the controls can see the current cards. This was not a mistake in policy: it was a deliberate choice that allowed Ryan Feldman to direct a more compelling show. Yet the investigative agency’s report suggests there were further weaknesses. Garrett strongly believes information was relayed to a control person, who relayed some sort of code to Robbi. Voila, cheating. I’m not sure this middle-man idea is necessary; Garrett implies it could be Luis. I don’t think so, as it makes little sense that Rip and Robbi would try to persuade two employees, as this doubles the risk and the payoff cost. Bryan Sagbigsal would be enough and likely had a more continuous form of access than a floor. Robbi would go out of her way to cover for him later. Garrett wants to pin something on Luis because of suspicious looking phone calls or access during the game, but I think Bryan is a far more likely suspect, even if the public long released their suspicions about him.

According to Garrett’s theory, Robbi received rather thoughtless messages through a vibrating device. This would be an onerous way to cheat, as everything is so unclear for her and so unnecessarily suspicious to the audience and the players. In fact, one of Robbi’s main themes at the table is her constant confusion. I attributed it before to inexperience and drugs, but what if it simply being baffled by her agreed duty at the table? In one hand, Garrett believes the signaler wants her to call turn to bluff river. All this is supposedly signaled via vibration; Garrett is really reaching here and seems to be destroying his own credibility, yet the accusation does underscore how difficult it is to make the cheating work. Even more absurdly, all this happens after the Postle scandal. Yet Garrett’s idea is that Rip is examining information between his legs, just like the maestro of secret information did. Once again, it’s either stupid or a different form of stupid.

Further, is Garrett really suggesting that Rip has some sort of screen device, while Robbi is given The Thumper? Is everyone just wilding out on equipment? The setting is so high, her body and the chair vibrate so much in the linked video, how could she have possibly agreed to use such an outrageously obvious device? Well, it could be because she is compromised and her ne’er do wells have her in a spot. Worse, when she relies on The Thumper in the Q4 hand, it’s an obvious fold spot. So those that argue it wasn’t needed every hand are clearly wrong: she’s relying on messages for every hand because she has no confidence in her game or decision making. Our potential colluders are the Three Stooges, 2022 poker version. There’s even a world where the information relayer was sending contradictory messages and Robbi ended up guessing what do against Garrett.

Still, the stooges got close to the money, successful or not. Sagbigsal takes $15,000 off Robbi’s stack. Let’s think about this. He could randomly be taking money; in fact, he could have been doing this for months. However, I think we would have heard about it after the initial investigation which found only one incidence. When Robbi gives back the money, Bryan lets out an audible cry of disappointment and decides to collect his payment on his own. (He’s a convicted felon and is not going to send an invoice.) Yet what is it a payment for exactly? It has to be something related to the hand and thus suggests real cheating was going on. Yet whatever information Sagbigsal has been passing on leaves Robbi consistently with no idea what to do. Garrett even creates a theory where she is asking for instructions via her own face scratching signal, when she should have been told via the vibration already. And what a signal! What if you just accidentally touch your face? Garrett’s idea either doesn’t make sense or it confirms the incompetence of the schemers.

I should probably leave the reader to his own enjoyment at this point, but Garrett does leave quite the file of circumstantial evidence at the bottom of the drawer. He does speculate that he has been cheated, but he spins no cohesive story. Honest enough. He says to go to his website for more information, but it’s all training material and PR materials. Suggesting he was cheated isn’t really enough, because there is no story. Well, if Garrett does not want to overspeculate, let me. Here’s a story that could be plausible:

Robbi is perpetually dissatisfied with her marriage and needs an excuse to get away from home, and this becomes poker. She is constantly starting affairs, emotional or not, and ends up with Rip Chavez, a player who frequents the kind of private games Robbi is attending during the Covid restrictions. Soon Robbi has quit her job, possibly avoiding a Covid layoff, thinking poker would supplant the income. However, by 2022 it does not; in fact she switches briefly to tournaments, looking for anything that will help her win. She is both in need of money to demonstrate her new career and has to keep Charles from knowing what is really going on. Rip also needs money to invest in his marijuana business. Robbi is likely a drug user of some sort, probably with access to expensive prescriptions having worked at Bayer for years. By the middle of 2022, and having found herself with several schemers including Darren “Beanz” Attebery, plans are being made. Robbi will be the singer because she is the least suspicious of them (yes I see the irony here), and anything she does is natural enough for an amateur. Robbi has never really been a poker player but she loves drama; the gravity of what they are going to do doesn’t really sink in. She pays off Beanz the HCL reg as part of the scheme, perhaps for his knowledge of the stream or as secrecy money for what is happening with Rip. By now, none of them have much cash so it has to be go time, even if the system is not perfect. Their inside man is Bryan, who has access to the tech and has spilled the beans over drinks. He is also known to be a felon by Rip or Beanz, both of whom have run businesses and therefore could have done background checks or some such research. Bryan will be responsible for the capturing the signals but only be paid afterwards because of the money situation. Bryan is not being paid much by HCL and so has a motivation plus a demonstrated willingness to commit illegalities. Bryan, according to the Bulletproof agency report which closes the book, could have accessed the stream from his personal computer or workstation as the network itself was not particularly secure, even in areas the creative director Feldman would have had little interest in. Bryan can easily have discovered this working unsupervised, long before September 2022. Next, Robbi goes on stream and they test it out. However, his efforts to communicate the results to Robbi are mixed and sometimes fail. On the big day, they all get lucky when Robbi makes the J4 call, initially angering Rip because it is so insane and a dangerous use of inside information, but he changes his tune when it looks like she might get away with it. However, Robbi has no idea what she is doing, appears to be caught in some way, and Garrett seizes on her attitude. Robbi, already a guilty person because of her personal life as well as being interested in fame and game show, gives back the money to try to salvage her place on the show; her life is slipping away. Bryan is outraged which explains his grabby fingers at the wrong time: he has to get paid for his risks and $15,000 is basically nothing: he takes the chips and likely thinks it should have been more. He later demands she cover for him because she has more to lose. Pressured again, Robbi composes the absurd letter covering for Bryan, something which she never expected to have to do and certainly was not capable of doing correctly. She fails multiple polygraphs, causing Rip to despair of their schemes. They break it off, each for different reasons. Rip agrees to whatever his wife Savannah demands of him to save his marriage, including sending information to Garrett. However, Robbi eventually passes one polygraph and this is the one that goes public. Rip, Darren, and Bryan all disappear from the scene, damaged but not in legal jeopardy at all because of California’s gaming laws. Garrett’s attempt at corning them with public information doesn’t take, as there is no coherent theory. The scandal stalls out. Robbi, now separated from Rip, goes on to play poker and be a social media presence while Garrett licks his wounds at home, in the greatest and most meaningful “blackout” of his life.

Well, that’s probably a bit wild but it is somewhat coherent and features actual explanatory motives, which is a quality lacking in most of the attempted accounts of what Rip and Robbi et al were up to. Yet there is still another big-ticket item to discuss: what does one make of Garrett’s decision to give back the money? Garrett feels uneasy about the $135,000 Robbi returned to him. He’s been remarkably fine with all sorts of other whale money – why not this time? Why not put it in a trust until the truth was more certain? Why not give it to Phil Galfond to steward? Instead of all these reasonable options, including just keeping it, Garrett donates it to the Big Brothers Big Sisters of Los Angeles. I have always found this incredibly unsatisfying and a bit too guilt tinged and certainly far too sudden. Yet it fits what we have learned about Garrett perfectly. He acts first and thinks later.

Why was this decision so deficient? The donation is essentially unsatisfying because Garrett is doing it out of an undeveloped conscience. It’s the same story he’s been telling about himself all along. The Big Brothers, which he worked for, are merely a lightning rod for his discomfort. In a word, it’s not fair. It’s short-sighted. The money should be set aside, even if only in his bank. Once again, Garrett’s mental energies are focused only on performance and enhancing that performance, not on developing a sound character or some philosophy of life to lean on. It’s the tragic flaw of a great poker player, man, and husband. Beneath the Cards is better for having exposed this aspect of his life, even if he did not mean to. Perhaps, after all, it is the flaw of many poker players: is Garrett our present-tense man, our representative? It would seem he is one of them, anyway. Having ingested hundreds of pages of him dealing with poker’s highs and lows, and after hiring therapists and quacks to better himself, the decision with the money now make sense to me. It doesn’t make his actions right. It also explains some of the malingering feeling the public seems to take up against Garrett: slight distrust. Admiration, but slight dislike.

A lot going on here at the end. The main narrative closes all too quickly. I’ll see what Garrett ends on and evaluate Beneath the Cards in my next post.

*

As if I were dreaming, the book concludes with Garrett confronting himself at last and confirming my theory that his efforts to deal with his inner life have been too restrictive and revolved mostly around ameliorating performance highs and lows. This impression that he had lacked a core or a code is directly addressed in Chapter 73, Identity.  Garrett has been sleepwalking through life, as most of us have, only to be awakened by the crisis. Does it really change him? Do we really change? I wonder how many stories and memoirs and autofictions are like this. Beneath the Cards is, in this sense, about more than just poker.

One reason I started reading Beneath the Cards was to address the rumor of A.I. having been used. The extraordinary numbers of clichés employed by the writer, if it is mostly Garrett, bites in different ways. For one, performers do think in cliché: listen to the latest post-match interview. It makes sense. High performers all think in the same way, poor performers all think differently, to paraphrase Coach Tolstoy. Yet I wonder if Garrett could even know all these bromides and idioms and metaphors and sayings and shortcuts. The software certainly does; it and its masters seem to think that is all there is to us meatbags.

However, I am not in the camp of the essentialists on almost anything. It does not matter to me if A.I. rewrote some of the text. On the balance, things are either quality or not quality. Yet the idea of autobiography seems to, well, throw a wrench in the machine, because we’re not supposed to be dealing with hallucinations. So there are some amusing paradoxes here. In the end, the A.I. is, for now, just a particularly effective secretary. It does not matter much, in the case of this autobio, what sort of stretching and mending went into its paragraphs.

“Zooming out, I recognized lifelong patterns of shifting identities, both internally (how I wanted to see myself) and externally, (how I hoped the world would see me).” Weirdly unnecessary parentheticals, there, bro. Anyway, Garrett feels he was like a recruit at boot camp, where his parents would “build him up and then tear him down,” and this explains his need for high performance. I wonder if it is that simple, but either way he has a moment where he can see that he is all persona, that he can discard this “perfectionism” as he calls it and move to a higher understanding of himself and the world. He seems to mostly want to do this. However, just when I am believing him, he drops another giant cliché on the reader’s head: “Ultimately, identity is a construct – an ever-evolving story I tell myself and the world. It isn’t real.” The therapy-speak has got him. “I’m enough,” he closes the chapter on, now mixing in some SNL to our moment of seriousness. We may be a construct, but what are we constructing? The opportunity seems somewhat fumbled. He’s decided that he’s just going to be nicer to himself, which is not much of a code.

This confusion explains the worst, most inaccurate line of Beneath the Cards, which closes Chapter 72, Acceptance. “I was the wrong guy, with the wrong issues, in the wrong place, at the wrong time.” No, it is exactly the opposite. Garrett was the right guy for this challenge in every way. Only a man like Garrett could stand up to Robbi in the way he did, and exactly as he did throughout his life. His story could not be more consistent. His issues are exactly the kind that are challenged by a real-life moment such as Robbi and her conspirators brought upon him. And of course he was in the right place at the right time, because the high, dangerous stakes are where Garrett lived and thrived. Jack-Four is Garrett’s domain in every way. A more philosophical mind would see this self-evidently; instead, he has dodged full self-knowledge and change at the end of his book. It’s one of the few things Garret gets wrong, and it is meaningful that he does, because life is only meaningful when challenged. Claiming he is just unlucky is an extraordinary cop-out. I now understand why he falls back on the identity clichés. The good news is, it’s only the end of his book, not the end of his life.

In Chapter 71 Garrett at last gives us his theory of what happened in Jack-Four. He provides no motivations or stories as I tried to do, but simply starts with the cheating, assuming the ring of rogues to be guilty. It’s worth noting that he proposes a more complicated signal than The Thumper video guy did. Garrett further suggests that HCL’s surveillance footage was not granted to Bulletproof, so that potential signaling was lost as evidence. Garrett notes that any illicit software could have been removed by Bryan, although he doesn’t state the obvious: the computer’s records are very likely to have a log of such an action. Or maybe Bryan is just that good at his job. It’s speculation, in the end.

Beneath the Cards is an easy and fun read. The end breaks down and the appendixes should have been incorporated into the story for the sake of drama and continuity. I feel like I was given a great deal of information about the crisis, but without a convincing presentation. We don’t get into his extraordinarily problematic father enough. His relationships are, with the exception of his mother, glossed over, primarily because Garrett really doesn’t think too much beyond himself and what he needs. In the first three quarters of the book, Garrett recaps his life breezily not because he has something particularly profound to say, but because he really was buoyed by favorable winds. Up until the crisis, of course.

Garrett’s story is important for his role in Jack-Four and as a symbol of poker’s contemporary challenges. Cheating, real-time assistance, and better learning technology are arriving in bigger waves than ever before. As for Garrett the man and player, he has revealed himself to be a prime example of the competitive gambler, an envied king of the game but one who well represents our dubious niche in society. If you are a poker player, you might try to emulate his greatness and avoid his weakness. If you are outside poker looking in, Beneath the Cards will instruct you about our sus little world. Enjoy.

Chris Murray, poker player and low stakes coach. persuadeo@gmail... etc.

3 Comments

  1. I recently read a piece by the Fed Bank of NY on Consumer Sentiment. The dude with a PhD in economics concluded that a person who received a raise that covers his cost of living will be less unhappy than a person who has to work extra hours or take a second job to cover his expenses.

    If that is the level of analysis, which pales in comparison to the effort of analysis you put forth in a book about a South Bay poker player, we get from the people running our country, we will get exactly what we deserve or the proles need to stop their surrogate activity bullshit (watching sports or poker horseshit).

    I’m not sure if I want to shake your hand for this piece or ask “what the fuck are you thinking.”

    Peace,

    F

    1. I do it for myself and for the band of brothers that care for it. The truth is that this is the short version. Good to hear from you, as always, and hope things are well in the paradise state.

  2. At least G-Sly didn’t go, as DFW pointed out about Tracy Austin: “Tracy Austin on the psychic rigors of competition: ‘Every professional athlete has to be so fine-tuned mentally”; “My Mother and Father never ever pushed me.”; Tract Austin on Martina Navratilova:”She is a wonderful person, very sensitive and caring.”

    I can’t believe you had the willpower to will-yourself through that pile of shit.

    F

Leave a comment